On 4 November the Home Office published its response to the consultation on a legal framework for law enforcement use of biometrics and facial recognition. It is the most substantial commitment any British government has made on this technology, and the headline commitments are real ones.
Two days later, Police Scotland hosted a demonstration of live facial recognition at its headquarters at Tulliallan, with the Scottish Police Authority and the Scottish Biometrics Commissioner in attendance, and officers from the national policing unit and Greater Manchester Police showing how it is used in England and Wales.
Those two events are a fortnight's news apart in the same feed. What connects them is a question almost nobody asked in the coverage of either: policing is devolved, and the law announced on 4 November does not run north of the border.
What was actually promised
Precision first, because the announcement has been reported in several places as though a law now exists.
It does not. The 4 November document is a government response setting out proposals, following a consultation that drew more than 13,800 replies. The legislation is to be introduced through the Police Reform Bill. No timetable was published.
What the proposals contain is nonetheless significant:
- A specific statutory requirement that police facial recognition deployments be intelligence-led and proportionate, used only where officers have grounds to believe wanted people may be present in an area.
- A single independent oversight body, consolidating and extending existing functions, with authority to check compliance and enforce standards. In serious cases it could seek a court injunction stopping a force from using a technology.
- A statutory code of practice developed with that regulator.
- Mandatory independent testing of law enforcement technologies for bias relating to age, sex and race.
- Public participation in oversight as a statutory requirement for forces and for the new body.
Injunction powers and statutory public participation are not cosmetic. The Home Office's own description of the status quo as a patchwork is accurate, and a regulator able to stop a deployment is a material change from a commissioner who can publish a report.
The government's case for the technology was made alongside it. The Home Secretary described facial recognition as the biggest breakthrough for catching criminals since DNA matching, while saying it must be fair, safe and proportionate. The Home Office cited 173 arrests from the Croydon fixed-camera pilot, and said that at this year's Notting Hill Carnival the technology was used to stop 86 registered sex offenders, seven of whom were arrested. Those are the department's own figures. A newly tested retrospective algorithm, which the Home Office says is highly accurate and free of bias, will be available to forces from next year.
The regulator consolidates two offices Scotland does not have
The design of the new body is where the devolution problem becomes concrete rather than theoretical.
The Home Office says the single oversight body will be designed taking account of the Biometrics and Surveillance Camera Commissioner and the Forensic Science Regulator. Scotland has neither. It has its own Scottish Biometrics Commissioner, operating under the Scottish Biometrics Commissioner Act with a statutory code of practice, and a markedly narrower remit.
So the consolidation being announced is a merger of functions that exist in one part of the United Kingdom and not the other. The resulting regulator, its code of practice and its bias-testing regime will apply to the forces of England and Wales.
Scotland, meanwhile, has no primary legislation governing police use of live facial recognition at all. Its Biometrics Commissioner, Dr Brian Plastow, has repeatedly asked Holyrood to legislate, and warned that Scotland could end up as one of only a handful of countries in Europe with no primary law covering police use of this class of biometric surveillance. The Scottish Government's position has been that use of any technology with live facial recognition capability is an operational matter for Police Scotland, subject to data protection law, the European Convention on Human Rights and the Commissioner's code.
The gap is not hypothetical
Police Scotland has not deployed live facial recognition operationally. That is often where the discussion stops, and it is where it should not.
Other UK policing bodies operate in Scotland, and some of them already have access to the technology. British Transport Police is the clearest example: a UK-wide force policing Scottish stations, with access to live facial recognition.
Plastow's warning is that if any of those bodies chose to deploy it in Scotland, it would fall outside his oversight. Not lightly regulated. Outside it.
Hold that against the 4 November announcement and the position is this. A deployment by a UK-wide force on a Scottish railway concourse would sit outside the new England and Wales regulator, because policing in Scotland is devolved, and outside the Scottish Biometrics Commissioner, because the bodies his functions extend to do not include it. Two regulators, one of them brand new and armed with injunction powers, and a space between them.
A deadline on 30 November that is getting no attention
There is a live decision point on exactly this, and it falls in under three weeks.
Under the Scottish Biometrics Commissioner Act, Scottish ministers must lay a report in the Scottish Parliament by no later than 30 November 2026 on whether the Commissioner's functions remain appropriate, and whether any bodies should be added to or removed from the list his functions extend to.
That is the mechanism by which the gap described above could be closed without primary legislation, or left open. It has attracted a fraction of the coverage given to the Home Office announcement, and it arrives first.
The technology nobody is legislating for
The second gap is about scope rather than geography, and this week's news is the clearest illustration of it.
Police Scotland is running a three-month proof of concept of the BriefCam video analytics platform, across roughly 100 cameras, from 14 September to 14 December 2026, on the public space CCTV system at Marischal College in Aberdeen. The trial uses object matching to search recorded footage at speed. BriefCam has facial recognition capability; the proposal explicitly excludes its use, with access restricted to trained software engineers.
On its own terms this is a cautious, well-bounded pilot, and the force deserves credit for publishing the proposal through the Scottish Police Authority rather than simply running it.
Two details complicate the picture. The software was bought jointly with Aberdeen City Council in 2020, when the CCTV system became jointly operated. And a review found Police Scotland had already been using it, with that use now paused while the governance around it is reviewed.
So the capability preceded the governance by around six years, and the pilot is in part a retrospective exercise in authorising something already happening. Regular readers will recognise the shape: this site's record of French national police use of the same platform documents an eight-year period of operation before the legal basis was examined, a suspension, an inspectorate report, and a resumption.
The wider point is that object-matching video analytics is not facial recognition. It is not obviously caught by a statutory framework written for biometrics, facial recognition and similar technologies, and nothing published on 4 November makes clear whether it would be. A law aimed at the technology that attracted the argument leaves adjacent capability, doing adjacent work on the same cameras, unaddressed.
And a purpose beyond policing
The third scope question surfaced on the same day as the announcement itself.
Government policy documents reported on 4 November set out plans to consider live facial recognition for general immigration enforcement, including possible use at transport hubs and public events, with the Home Office confirming it was examining further trials.
The framework announced that week covers law enforcement bodies and other public bodies for law enforcement and limited safeguarding purposes. Whether immigration enforcement by the Home Office sits inside that definition is not spelled out in anything published so far, and it matters a great deal: it determines whether the department writing the rules is also bound by them.
Separately, the question of private-sector use remains partly open. The policing minister's written statement says the Bill will include complementary measures to keep rules for private-sector facial recognition consistent with law enforcement use where appropriate. The Ada Lovelace Institute has argued the retail code should be made mandatory rather than voluntary. "Where appropriate" is carrying a lot of weight in that sentence.
The rollout is not waiting
None of this is happening in a pause.
Suffolk Constabulary deployed live facial recognition across three locations in early November, beginning in Lowestoft on 3 November. Avon and Somerset Police announced on 5 November that it will introduce the technology. The £11m committed to tripling the number of live facial recognition vans available in England and Wales is already allocated. The new retrospective algorithm reaches forces next year.
The Home Office is explicit that expansion and regulation are moving together, and there is a respectable argument for that sequencing: a regulator designed around a deployed estate knows what it is regulating, and the consultation found public support for the technology alongside demands for safeguards.
The counter-argument is equally plain. Statutory powers that exist only on paper until a bill passes do not constrain a deployment happening this month, and the shape of a framework written after the fact tends to follow the shape of what is already there.
The United Kingdom record on this tracker now holds 129 entries, more than any country except the United States. A substantial and growing share are facial recognition in one form or another.
What would settle the open questions
Five documents would answer almost everything above, and none has appeared yet:
- The scope clause of the Police Reform Bill as introduced, which will show whether the framework reaches beyond facial recognition to other AI video analytics.
- The report Scottish ministers must lay by 30 November on the Biometrics Commissioner's functions and the bodies they cover.
- Any statement on whether Home Office immigration enforcement falls inside the new regulator's remit.
- An explanation of how the new body will divide responsibilities with the Information Commissioner's Office, which already regulates police processing of personal data and audited five forces on facial recognition this year. Nothing published so far addresses this.
- The outcome of the Aberdeen BriefCam proof of concept on 14 December, and the governance review of the force's earlier use of the same software.
The announcement on 4 November was a serious piece of work and a genuine strengthening of a framework that badly needed one. The question it leaves is not whether facial recognition will be regulated in Britain. It is whether a law named after one technology, in one of three jurisdictions, can govern a capability that is already spreading across all three boundaries at once.