United Kingdom, Essex
Essex Police
Knife Crime and Violence Model (Fearless Futures)
TrialOfficial publicationPAI-DDAF5C08
- Body
- Essex Police
- Country
- United Kingdom
- Area
- Essex
- Technology
- Knife Crime and Violence Model (Fearless Futures)
- Supplier
- Not stated in the source
- Status
- Trial
Being tested in live conditions under a time-limited pilot or trial. - Stage
- In use now
- Since
- Not known
- Legal basis
- Law enforcement purposes under the Data Protection Act 2018 for Essex Police and the Probation Service; for partners, UK GDPR Article 6(1)(e) with the Schedule 1 paragraph 10 condition for criminal offence data (as stated in the force privacy notice).
- Oversight
- Processing by the force's Performance Analysis Unit under a data scientist's supervision; Essex Police and the Probation Service are joint controllers under an information sharing agreement; the privacy notice says no decisions are based on automation alone.
- Evidence
- Official publication
Police force, government department or public body publication - Source
- Essex Police privacy notice, Knife Crime and Violence Model (Fearless Futures), version 1.4 (June 2021)
- Last checked
- Record code
PAI-DDAF5C08
Notes
Essex Police's privacy notice for the Knife Crime and Violence Model, known through its support programme as Fearless Futures, (version 1.4, dated June 2021) describes a project to assess people at heightened risk of becoming involved in serious knife-enabled violence. It uses police-recorded data from the force's Athena system, processes all Athena data subjects with a home address in Essex, and gives each person a risk score; those at 30 per cent and above are prioritised for allocation to a partner such as the Probation Service under the Violence and Vulnerability Unit. The privacy notice does not list the data items used and appears to give two thresholds (below and at or above 0.3) without explaining how they relate. A College of Policing case study (details accurate as of March 2023) says the model estimates how likely each person known to police is to commit a new knife or violent offence within 12 months, using factors such as age, gender, number of criminal associates and prior suspect or victim status in violence-with-injury cases, was built by Essex Police data scientists with the University of Essex, was tested for 18 months with 'accurate predictions of risk' but no published metrics, and recommends a longer trial in more locations. A force FOI response of 24 February 2022 said the force runs a risk model, Fearless Futures, 'which uses an algorithmic approach to determine risk' and is 'not predictive', and that it has 'no programmes that attempt to predict if individuals are likely to commit crime'; that description sits uneasily with the College of Policing's account of a model estimating the likelihood of new offences, and both are recorded here. Whether the model is in routine use now has not been found, so the status is recorded as a trial.
Other systems used by Essex Police
| Deployment | Country | Supplier | Since | Status | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Essex PoliceLive Facial Recognition | United KingdomForce area | Corsight AI (Apollo 4), with Digital Barriers | 2024 | Operational | |
| Essex PoliceRetrospective facial recognition (Police National Database search) | United KingdomEssex | — | — | Operational |
Knife Crime and Violence Model (Fearless Futures) elsewhere in United Kingdom
See them in the tracker| Deployment | Country | Supplier | Since | Status | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Avon and Somerset PolicePredictive Analytics Programme | United KingdomAvon and Somerset | Built in-house | 2017 | Operational | |
| Bristol City CouncilThink Family Database and child exploitation risk models | United KingdomBristol | Not specified | 2016 | Discontinued | |
| Ministry of JusticeIndividual Risk Scoring | United KingdomEngland and Wales (research phase) | Developed in-house (Ministry of Justice data science team) | 2023 | Proposed | |
| Lincolnshire PoliceCESIUM child exploitation risk identification | United KingdomLincolnshire | Trilateral Research (CESIUM) | 2023 | Operational | |
| Nottinghamshire PoliceCESIUM child exploitation risk identification | United KingdomNottinghamshire | Trilateral Research | 2024 | Trial |