Digital forensics

Forensic science increasingly relies on algorithms: to interpret DNA mixtures, suggest fingerprint matches, enhance CCTV and sort the vast volume of data on seized phones. Any tool that produces evidence for court must meet the Forensic Science Regulator's standards.

Guide

What it is

  • Probabilistic genotyping software such as STRmix interprets DNA samples containing more than one person's profile and reports a likelihood ratio.
  • Fingerprint matching automated systems such as NAFIS suggest candidate matches that a human examiner then assesses.
  • Digital triage tools from companies such as Cellebrite and MSAB sort data extracted from devices and flag what looks relevant, including known abuse images.
  • Image and video analysis enhancement, gait and clothing comparison, and facial comparison applied to footage.

How it is used

Forces use these tools to cut backlogs, as seized devices can wait months or years to be examined, and to produce evidence for prosecutions. Since 2021 the Forensic Science Regulator has been able to issue binding codes requiring validated methods. The record tracks tools in use, the Regulator's warnings, and court rulings on algorithmic evidence.

Key tensions

Validation

AI tools can be accurate on average but unreliable in an individual case or for some groups, and the Regulator has warned that adoption is outpacing validation.

Secret algorithms in court

Defence experts in the US and Australia have been refused access to DNA software source code on commercial grounds. How far a defendant can examine a proprietary algorithm is unresolved in the UK.

Enhancement that invents detail

The Regulator has warned that AI enhancement can add artefacts that were never in the original footage, and enhanced images have been shown in court without adequate explanation.

View all digital forensics records Latest coverage

In depth

The full guide, about 7 minutes to read.

The Forensic Science Regulator and the quality standards framework

Forensic science in England and Wales operates under the oversight of the Forensic Science Regulator, a role that existed on a non-statutory basis from 2008 and was placed on a statutory footing by the Forensic Science Regulator and Biometric Strategy Act 2021. The significance of that change from advisory to statutory is not merely symbolic: the Regulator can now issue legally binding Codes of Practice and Conduct, and has the power to compel compliance from providers and processes used in criminal proceedings where those standards are not met. Any AI tool used to generate evidence for use in court falls within scope.

The Regulator's Codes require forensic science processes to be validated (that is, demonstrated to be fit for the specific purpose for which they are used) and to meet the requirements of ISO/IEC 17025, the international standard for testing and calibration laboratories. Validation is a demanding requirement even for well-established techniques. For AI systems, which may produce outputs that are statistically accurate in aggregate but unreliable in individual cases, or which may perform differently across different demographic groups or environmental conditions, the validation requirement raises questions that do not have settled answers. The Regulator has published guidance on the validation of digital forensics tools and has flagged concerns about the pace at which AI-enabled tools are being adopted into casework before adequate validation frameworks are in place.

DNA analysis and probabilistic genotyping

The most extensively used AI application in forensic science is arguably probabilistic genotyping, the use of statistical software to interpret complex DNA mixtures where the profiles of two or more individuals are present in the same sample. Traditional binary interpretation of DNA mixtures (either a profile is included or it is not) was recognised as having significant limitations when samples are degraded, when there are more than two contributors, or when the relative proportions of different individuals' DNA in a mixture are unequal. Probabilistic genotyping software such as STRmix, developed in New Zealand and used by the Forensic Science Service's successor laboratories and by several national police forces, produces a likelihood ratio that expresses how much more probable the evidence is if the suspect contributed to the mixture than if they did not.

The introduction of probabilistic genotyping has been broadly welcomed by forensic scientists as improving the accuracy and objectivity of mixture interpretation. It has also, however, given rise to a series of contentious appeal cases. The software's underlying source code has been the subject of disclosure disputes in both the United States and Australia, where defence experts sought access to examine the algorithm's methodology and were resisted on the grounds of commercial confidentiality. In the UK context, the principle that defendants are entitled to sufficient information about expert evidence to mount an effective challenge is well-established, but what that means in practice when the evidence is generated by a proprietary algorithm whose full workings are not publicly available remains a live and unresolved tension.

A separate concern relates to the validation of probabilistic genotyping software for the specific mixture types to which it is applied in casework. Software validated on two-person mixtures may not perform equivalently when applied to three- or four-person mixtures, and validation data generated under laboratory conditions may not fully capture the variability of real casework samples. The Forensic Science Regulator has flagged these as areas requiring ongoing attention.

Automated fingerprint identification

Automated fingerprint identification systems (AFIS) have been used by UK law enforcement since the 1980s, making them among the earliest AI applications in policing. The National Automated Fingerprint Identification System (NAFIS), operated by the National Policing Improvement Agency's successor functions, holds millions of ten-print records from individuals who have been arrested or charged, as well as a substantial database of scene-of-crime marks. The system generates a ranked list of candidate matches that a human fingerprint examiner then reviews and evaluates against the ACE-V methodology: Analysis, Comparison, Evaluation, and Verification.

The human review step is not merely procedural: fingerprint examination retains significant subjective elements even when AI is used to generate candidate matches, and the literature on cognitive bias in fingerprint examination is substantial and troubling. Studies have shown that fingerprint examiners presented with contextual information suggesting a suspect is guilty are more likely to reach a positive identification than when presented with identical prints without that context. The AI candidate list can inadvertently create its own form of contextual bias by presenting only the highest-scoring candidates for human review, effectively narrowing the examiner's frame of reference before they have looked at the evidence.

More recent developments include the application of convolutional neural networks to fingerprint enhancement (improving the quality of degraded or partial marks before they are submitted for comparison) and to the identification of partial palm prints, which traditional AFIS systems handled less reliably. These applications are in varying stages of operational deployment in UK forces.

Digital forensics and AI triage

The volume of digital evidence in modern criminal investigations has grown to a scale that is genuinely unmanageable without automated assistance. A single smartphone seized during an investigation may contain hundreds of thousands of messages, images, and data records. A single laptop may hold terabytes of data. Forces across England and Wales report significant backlogs in the examination of digital devices, with devices sometimes sitting unexamined for months or years while suspects await trial.

AI-assisted triage tools (software products such as those developed by Cellebrite and MSAB) use machine learning to classify and prioritise data extracted from devices, flagging items likely to be of investigative relevance for priority examination by a human analyst. Child sexual abuse material detection, in particular, has seen widespread adoption of AI-assisted hashing and classification tools: Photodna, developed by Microsoft and operated in partnership with the Internet Watch Foundation, compares digital fingerprints of images against a database of known illegal material and is used by forces and major technology platforms alike. The tool does not by itself produce evidence for court (a human analyst must verify any match) but it enables investigators to identify material that would be physically impossible to review manually at scale.

The legal framework governing digital forensics has not kept pace with these developments. Questions about the chain of custody of data extracted by AI tools, the admissibility of AI-generated metadata analysis, and the disclosure obligations of forces when AI triage tools make decisions about what a human examiner sees and does not see are all insufficiently settled in domestic case law. The Law Commission's review of admissibility of expert evidence (an ongoing project as of the mid-2020s) touches on some of these issues but has not yet resolved them.

AI in forensic imagery and video analysis

Forensic video analysis has long been a specialist discipline, involving the enhancement, interpretation, and comparison of CCTV and other visual evidence. AI has transformed what is possible in this field over the past decade. Enhancement algorithms can recover detail from compressed or low-resolution footage that would previously have been unusable. Gait analysis software can compare the way a suspect moves against footage of an unknown individual at a crime scene. Clothing comparison tools can identify matching garments across different video sequences. And facial comparison (distinct from live facial recognition) can be used to assess whether an individual shown in crime scene footage is consistent with a suspect, though the admissibility and probative weight of such comparisons has been the subject of significant judicial and academic scrutiny.

The Forensic Science Regulator has expressed particular concern about the use of AI enhancement tools in a forensic context, noting that enhancement algorithms can introduce artefacts (visual elements that are not present in the original image but are generated by the algorithm) and that examiners need specific training to identify and account for this risk. The concern is not theoretical: there are documented cases in the forensic literature of enhanced images being presented in court without adequate explanation of the enhancement process, raising the possibility that juries have placed weight on details that were, in a meaningful sense, invented by software.

The admissibility of algorithmic evidence

The admissibility of AI-generated forensic evidence in criminal proceedings engages a cluster of interrelated legal principles: the requirements for expert evidence, the defendant's right to examine the evidence against them, the prosecution's disclosure obligations, and the court's gatekeeping role in relation to potentially misleading or unreliable evidence. None of these principles were designed with AI in mind, and their application to algorithmic outputs is not always straightforward.

Expert evidence in England and Wales is admissible where it is within the expert's area of expertise and assists the court in a way that goes beyond what the jury could determine unaided. Where an AI tool generates the output that the expert then interprets, questions arise about whether the expert can genuinely explain the basis for the output, how error rates should be communicated to the jury, and whether the opacity of a proprietary algorithm is compatible with the defendant's right under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights to examine the evidence against them. These questions are being worked out incrementally in individual cases rather than addressed by any overarching legislative or judicial framework, which creates significant inconsistency in how AI forensic evidence is handled across different courts and jurisdictions.

Records on the tracker

Open the full tracker

24 records on digital forensics, most recently checked first: 17 in use now, 0 withdrawn and 7 on the horizon. Each is one police force or public body using one system.

  1. Latvia

    Valsts policija (Latvian State Police) — AI tools for analysing large volumes of digital data in Baltic languages for intelligence and investigations (project VP/IDF/2026/1)

    Latvia, Main Criminal Police Department, Cybercrime Combating Unit

    In developmentChecked
  2. Slovenia

    Slovenian Police — ABIS forensic facial comparison and video analysis

    Slovenia, national; National Forensic Laboratory

    ProposedChecked
  3. United StatesAmped (as listed in the inventory)2025

    US Secret Service — Licence plate reading from poor-quality images and video (forensic)

    Nationwide

    OperationalChecked
  4. United StatesTRM Labs2022

    ICE Homeland Security Investigations — TRM Labs blockchain analysis

    Nationwide

    OperationalChecked
  5. United StatesCellebrite2023

    ICE Homeland Security Investigations — Cellebrite media classifier for digital evidence

    Nationwide

    OperationalChecked
  6. United States

    US Immigration and Customs Enforcement — AI mobile device forensics triage

    Nationwide

    ProposedChecked
  7. United States

    ICE Homeland Security Investigations — Semantic search and summarisation of investigative, translated and digital forensics data (three planned tools)

    Nationwide

    ProposedChecked
  8. United StatesTRM Labs2025

    US Customs and Border Protection — TRM Labs cryptocurrency analysis

    Nationwide

    OperationalChecked
  9. United States

    US Customs and Border Protection — AI triage of smartphone content during inspection

    ProposedChecked
  10. United States

    Drug Enforcement Administration — Drug Signature Program models (origin and manufacturing route of seized drugs)

    Nationwide

    OperationalChecked
  11. United States

    Drug Enforcement Administration — Friction ridge print comparison and print-card character recognition

    Nationwide

    OperationalChecked
  12. United States

    Drug Enforcement Administration — Financial and cryptocurrency analysis tools (federal partner and commercial)

    Nationwide

    OperationalChecked
  13. United StatesPenLink

    Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives — PenLink PLX forensic analysis and link analysis

    Nationwide

    OperationalChecked
  14. United StatesCellebrite, Magnet Axiom and Griffeye (examples named in the inventory)

    US Department of Justice — AI features in digital forensics tools (for example Cellebrite, Magnet Axiom, Griffeye)

    Nationwide

    OperationalChecked
  15. United States

    Office of the State Prosecutor (Maryland) — ScanWriter document analysis for fraud investigations

    Maryland

    OperationalChecked
  16. United Kingdom

    Swansea University — DRAGON-Spotter (AI linguistic detection of online grooming in seized-device chat logs)

    Swansea

    In developmentChecked
  17. United KingdomOpenText (Axcelerate, per the SFO's 2018 announcement)2018

    Serious Fraud Office — AI-assisted document review and technology assisted review

    OperationalChecked
  18. France

    Gendarmerie nationale — PJGN AI investigative tools platform (speech-to-text, object detection, translation)

    OperationalChecked
  19. Germany

    Landeskriminalamt Mecklenburg-Vorpommern — NN-Toolkit (TensorFlow-based image similarity search for digital forensics)

    Mecklenburg-Vorpommern

    OperationalChecked
  20. Switzerland

    fedpol (Swiss Federal Office of Police) — AI programs for sifting seized data (images, audio, video, text)

    Federal

    OperationalChecked
  21. GermanyChainalysis Inc.2021

    Bayerisches Landeskriminalamt — Chainalysis Reactor cryptocurrency transaction analysis

    Bavaria

    OperationalChecked
  22. GermanyTRM Labs

    Bayerisches Landeskriminalamt — TRM Labs Forensics cryptocurrency transaction analysis

    Bavaria

    ProposedChecked
  23. United KingdomCellebrite2018

    Metropolitan Police — Mobile device extraction (Cellebrite)

    London

    OperationalChecked
  24. Czech RepublicMultiple: BriefCam, Magnet AXIOM, Cellebrite UFED, Phonexia, Newton, ABBYY FineReader2026

    Czech Police — AI and machine learning forensic tools

    Czech Republic, national

    OperationalChecked

Latest coverage